RT Journal Article
T1 Prosthetic limbs on display
A1 Sophie Goggins
A1 Tacye Phillipson
A1 Samuel J M M Alberti
YR 2017
VO 8
IS Autumn 2017
K1 disability
K1  prosthetics
K1  users
K1  war
AB Prosthetic devices have been used in museums to tell clinical, technical and personal stories. Here we reflect on the ways artificial limbs and their users were represented in recent museum projects at the Royal College of Surgeons of England and at National Museums Scotland. We consider how these meaningful artefacts illuminate three overlapping themes in museum scholarship and practice: the representation of disabled people and disability in museums; reflections on conflict-acquired limb loss; and the presence or otherwise of user or patient voice in interpretation. In working with and representing people who design and wear prosthetics we advocate a balance between narratives of technique and of use.
NO Sam Alberti project managed War, Art and Surgery; Tacye Phillipson curated Reconstructing Lives and co-curated Shaping our World; Sophie Goggins co-curated Technology by Design. Our thanks also to Elsa Cox, Stewart Emmens, Louise Innes, Xerxes Mazda, Julia Midgley and two referees. Views expressed are the authors’ own, and do not necessarily reflect those of their colleagues on these projects, nor the institutions involved.
NO Julia Midgley email to Sam Alberti, 22 December 2016
NO Reconstructing Lives, exhibition text, 2012 (quoting 2008), National Museums Scotland
NO All from Reconstructing Lives exhibition comments books 2012–13, National Museums Scotland
NO Chris Moon MBE, Reconstructing Lives exhibition video, recorded 2012, National Museums Scotland
NO Shaping our World, gallery text, 2011, National Museums Scotland
NO Allan Shannon email to Sophie Goggins, 7 April 2016
NO Yvonne Kavanagh email to Sophie Goggins, 11 April 2016
PB The Science Museum Group
SN 2054-5770
LA eng
DO 10.15180/170806
UL http://journal.sciencemuseum.ac.uk/browse/issue-08/prosthetic-limbs-on-display/
CR Alberti, S J M M (ed), 2014, War, Art and Surgery: The work of Henry Tonks and Julia Midgley (London: Royal College of Surgeons)
CR Alberti, S J M M, 2016, ‘Finding patients in the medical museum’, British Society for the History of Medicine Poynter Lecture [video], available at: http://bshm.org.uk/poynter-lecture-video (accessed 4 December 2016)
CR Anderson, J and O’Sullivan, L, 2010, ‘Histories of disability and medicine: Reconciling historical narratives and contemporary values’, in Sandell, R, Dodd, J and Garland-Thomas, R (eds), Re-presenting disability (London and New York: Routledge), pp 143–154
CR Anon, 1964, ‘In a basement full of miracles’, Scottish Daily Express, 20 July
CR Arnold, K and Olsen, D, 2003, Medicine man (London: British Museum Press)
CR Bamji, A, 2017, Faces from the front: Harold Gillies, the Queen's Hospital, Sidcup, and the Origins of Modern Plastic Surgery (Solihull: Helion)
CR Bolton, G, 2010, Reflective practice: Writing and professional development, third edition (London: SAGE)
CR Boon, T, 2011, ‘Co-Curation and the public history of science and technology’, Curator: The Museums Journal, 54/4, pp 383–387
CR Carden-Coyne, A, 2010, ‘Ghosts in the war museum’, in Sandell, R, Dodd, J and Garland-Thomson, R (eds), Re-Presenting disability: Activism and agency in the museum (London and New York: Routledge), pp 64–78
CR Corn, J J, 2011, User unfriendly: Consumer struggles with personal technologies, from clocks and sewing machines to cars and computers (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press)
CR Delin, A, 2002, ‘Buried in the footnotes: the absence of disabled people in the collective imagery of our past’, in Sandell, R (ed), Museums, society, inequality (London and New York: Routledge), pp 84–97
CR Dodd, J, et al, 2010, ‘Disability reframed: Challenging visitor perceptions in the museum’, in Sandell, R, Dodd, J and Garland-Thomas, R (eds), Re-presenting disability: Activism and agency in the museum (London and New York: Routledge), pp 92–111
CR Dolan, M and Gow, D, 2013, ‘Half a century of clinical bioengineering in Edinburgh’, SCOPE, 22 (2), pp 11–17, available at: https://www.ipem.ac.uk/portals/0/documents/publications/scope/scopejun13web.pdf (accessed 4 April 2016)
CR Emmens, S, 2003, Consequences of thalidomide, Ingenious: Seeing things differently, available at: http://www.ingenious.org.uk/Read/Health/Livingwithartificiallimbs/ConsequencesofThalidomide (accessed 6 January 2017)
CR Emmens, S, 2010, Arms, legs and ex-servicemen [Blog] Science Museum Blog, available at: https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/arms-legs-and-ex-servicemen (accessed 11 December 2016)
CR Emmens, S, 2016, Wounded: Conflict, casualties and care [Blog] Science Museum Blog, available at: https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/wounded-conflict-casualties-and-care (accessed 11 December 2016)
CR Foxtrot Films, 2015, War art with Eddie Redmayne, first broadcast ITV 24 May 2015
CR Freeth, S, 2016, Wounded: From shell shock to PTSD [Blog] Science Museum Blog, available at: https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/wounded-from-shell-shock-to-ptsd (accessed 7 December 2016)
CR Gosling, J, 2012, Abnormal: How Britain became body dysphoric and the key to a cure (London: Bettany Press)
CR Gow, D, 1999, ‘The development of the Edinburgh modular arm system’, paper presented at MyoElectric Controls/Powered Prosthetics Symposium ’99 (Fredericton, Canada: University of New Brunswick)
CR Hansard, 1972 (Parliamentary Debates), HC Deb 29 November, vol 847 col 469
CR Hume, V (ed), 2008, Transplant (London: Royal Brompton & Harefield Arts)
CR Larsen, F, 2009, An infinity of things: How Sir Henry Wellcome collected the world (Oxford: Oxford University Press)
CR Lynch, B T, 2011, ‘Custom-made reflective practice: Can museums realise their capabilities in helping others realise theirs?’, Museum Management and Curatorship, 26(5), pp 441–458
CR McCarthy, C, 2015, ‘Grounding museum studies: Introducing Practice’, in McCarthy, C (ed), The international handbooks of museum studies, vol 2, Museum practice (Chichester: Wiley), pp xxxv–lii
CR Maguire, C, 1998, ‘I’m proud to shoulder the responsibility for testing bionic arm’, Daily Mail, 13 May
CR Midgley, J, 2014, ‘Julia Midgley’s work’, in Alberti, S J M M (ed), War, Art and Surgery: The work of Henry Tonks and Julia Midgley (London: Royal College of Surgeons), pp 162–347
CR Muncie, S and Hutcheson, L, 2016, ‘National Museum Scotland Summative Evaluation: Visitor Research’, National Museums Scotland
CR Oliveira Barata, S, 2013, Anatomical Leg, ‘The Alternative Limb Project’, http://www.thealternativelimbproject.com/project/anatomical-leg (accessed 4 December 2016)
CR Ott, K, 2002, ‘The sum of its parts: An introduction to modern histories of prosthetics’, in Ott, K, Mihm, S and Serlin, D (eds), Artificial parts, practical lives: Modern histories of prosthetics (New York: New York University Press), pp 1–42
CR Ott, K, 2005, ‘Carnage remembered: Prosthetics in the US Military since the 1860s’, in Finn, B and Hacker, B C (eds), Materializing the Military (London: Cromwell Press), pp 47–64
CR Ott, K, 2010, ‘What museums do for disability studies’, in Sandell, R, Dodd, J and Garland-Thomson, R (eds), Re-Presenting disability: Activism and agency in the museum (London and New York: Routledge), pp 269–279
CR Ott, K, et al, 2013, EveryBody: An artifact history of disability in America, available at: https://everybody.si.edu (accessed 18 December 2016)
CR Oudshoorn, N and Pinch, T (eds), 2003, How users matter: The co-construction of users and technology (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press)
CR Reid, A, 2013, Standing tall: The inspirational story of a true British hero (London: Blake)
CR Reznick, J S, 2004, ‘Prostheses and propaganda: Materiality and the human body in the Great War’, in Saunders, N (ed), Matters of conflict: Material culture, memory and the First World War (London: Routledge), pp 51–61
CR Royal College of Surgeons of England, 2007, Exhibiting difference, available at: www.rcseng.ac.uk/museums-and-archives/hunterian-museum/exhibitions/past-exhibitions/exhibiting-difference (accessed 4 December 2016)
CR Royal College of Surgeons of England, 2012, Anatomy of an athlete, available at: www.rcseng.ac.uk/museums-and-archives/hunterian-museum/exhibitions/past-exhibitions/anatomy-athlete (accessed 4 December 2016)
CR Sandell, R, 2007, Museums, prejudice and the reframing of difference (London and New York: Routledge)
CR Sandell, R, Delin, A, Dodd, J and Gay, J, 2005, ‘Beggars, freaks and heroes: Museums and the hidden history of disability’, in Museum Management and Curatorship, 20/2, pp 5–19
CR Sandell, R and Dodd, J, 2010, ‘Activist practice’, in Sandell, R, Dodd, J and Garland-Thomson, R (eds), Re-Presenting disability: Activism and agency in the museum (London and New York: Routledge), pp 3–22
CR Schnalke, T, 2013, ‘Tracing life: The Berlin Museum of Medical History at the Charité’, in Alberti, S J M M and Hallam, E (eds), Medical museums: Past, present, future (London: Royal College of Surgeons), pp 130–143
CR Shakespeare, T, 2016, ‘The social model of disability’, in Davis, L J (ed), The disability studies reader, fifth edition (New York: Routledge), pp 195–203
CR Telfer, B, Shepley, E and Reeves, C, 2011, Re-framing disability: Portraits from the Royal College of Physicians (London: Royal College of Physicians)
CR Thompson, P, 2011, ‘Brave Lt. Dave Henson talks about recovering after losing his legs in Afghanistan’, The Argus, available at: www.theargus.co.uk/news/9144985.Fighting_spirit_of_brave_Hampshire_soldier (accessed 18 December 2016)
CR ‘Victoria’, 2012, ‘Viewpoints’, Wandering on course: Tales of a traveling artist, available at: http://wanderingoncourse.blogspot.co.uk/2012/07/viewpoints.html(accessed 18 December 2016)
CR Walton, C, 2014, ‘Reconstruction and rehabilitation’, in Alberti, S J M M (ed), War, Art and Surgery: The work of Henry Tonks and Julia Midgley (London: Royal College of Surgeons), pp 316–317
WT Science Museum Group Journal
OL 30